personally i read his critics and i found them really interesting in what it was written and the way they were written.
they were not too condescending in my opinion.
but as we know a critic is subjective.
we can always disagree with a critic.
and opinions

I think with these arena beats there is room for (constructively) harsh critique. These challenges often run shorter than a week. The short period for creation combined with life's own schedule lead many of us to assemble our entries while capitalizing on our own freedoms. Hearing negative feedback on a track you put your heart into may be hard, but I think these beats should be looked at as sketches of our own creative processes and where we are as artists. I use the arena to test out new ideas, experiment with sampling techniques or even let loose old styles I don't use as often as I used to. I recognize the criticism and while disagreeing often, take it into consideration when crafting future music.

100% cosign

what does the amount of soundcloud followers and self indulgent have to do with a track ??? lmao !!!